The cooling system or popularly known as the “radiator” is probably not the most exciting element of the investment when you map out the stages of your car building. As a result, when you have to go looking for a new radiator, you come across a wide range of options available to fit your automobile. Will a four-core copper-brass radiator and a two-row aluminum radiator perform as well? Which product cools quicker, and why?
Aluminium radiators and copper radiators are both often utilized in contemporary automobiles. Radiators are typically made of one of these materials. Because of their physical characteristics, copper and aluminum are both used. Each material has advantages and disadvantages.
What is an Aluminium Radiator?
Aluminium radiators are heat exchangers that are used to move thermal energy from one medium to another for the purpose of heating. Aluminium is a fantastic element to use to construct radiators because it is a great heat conductor. Due to the excellent heat conductivity of aluminum, radiators constructed of aluminum reach the desired temperature more quickly than radiators made of other materials.
What is a Copper Radiator?
Copper radiators are, as their name implies, constructed of copper. The only material utilized to make radiators in older times was copper. Copper has a better heat conductivity; hence it was utilized in the earlier times. The ideal metal for radiators in trucks has always been copper. It is perfect for this use due to its exceptional thermal conductivity, corrosion resistance, and strength.
So What is The Difference?
The primary distinction between the two radiator types is largely attributable to the materials used, as well as the size of the tubes and the type of fins.
Copper isn't the only material found in radiators; it's frequently combined with other metals and alloys such as brass and lead. The narrower tubes and fins of a copper radiator, on the other hand, are mostly made of copper. Aluminium radiators, on the other hand, have much wider tubing and are typically combined with steel alloys.
However, the two types differ significantly in terms of heat conductivity, cooling capabilities, durability, weight, and so on. Continue reading to find out more.
Because copper has less strength than aluminum as a metal, tubes must be made thin in order to keep the radiator cool. Because aluminum has greater strength, its tubes can be made wider, resulting in a better cooling effect. Wide tubes allow for direct contact between fins and tube, resulting in faster heat dissipation.
Both copper and aluminum, however, have advantages. Copper's heat conductivity is far superior to that of aluminum. Copper radiators are also easier to repair. Aluminium, on the other hand, is much lighter and stronger than copper. Those who are more concerned with appearance prefer aluminum that can be polished to a mirror-like finish.
Copper Brass:-
Uses More Rows and Tubes
Base heat transfer ability is higher
Heavier in weight
The use of lead/tin solder results in a mixed metal core
The solder reduces the heat transfer ability.
Aluminium:-
Base heat transfer ability is lower
Light weight
Uses lesser rows and tubes
Produced through the process of brazing
The heat transfer is uniformed due to all aluminum core
The Judgement: Aluminium is a long-lasting metal that is corrosion-resistant due to a thin layer of aluminum oxide, and it can withstand heavy handling because it is more malleable and elastic than steel. Furthermore, the metal has an extremely low mass for its volume; it is 2.5 times less dense than steel, making installation far easier for you or your installer than alternative materials.
Aluminium is far more environmentally friendly than steel; not only does it require less energy to produce the raw material, but it also requires less energy and water to heat the radiator. As previously stated, this is better for you and the environment because you can save money on your bills. Aluminium is also 100% recyclable and is frequently made from recycled materials, making it more environmentally friendly in the long run.
Which is The Best for You?
1. The price distinction between copper and aluminum radiators
At the moment, the market price of copper materials far outweighs the price of aluminum materials. Copper materials are several times more expensive than aluminum materials in terms of cost alone. As a result, in order to save money, many automotive radiator manufacturers and buyers will prefer aluminum car radiators.
2. The difference in welding between copper and aluminum car radiators
Soldering is used to join the copper car radiator for sale. The welding medium is tin, which is achieved by melting and cooling tin, whereas the welding of aluminum car radiators is brazing of aluminum, which uses the different melting points of different aluminum alloys, as well as melting and cooling of the aluminum alloy itself in a specific atmosphere. The aluminum car radiator has no excess components doping, ensuring consistent performance from start to finish.
3. The difference in heat dissipation capacity between copper and aluminum automobile radiators
Copper materials have a relatively high heat dissipation coefficient. Copper products therefore have a higher heat dissipation capacity than aluminum products. However, because welding of copper materials is dependent on the melting and cooling of tin, there is a layer of tin-lead alloy hanging on the surface of the copper car radiator's heat pipe and main sheet. Although copper has a higher heat dissipation coefficient than aluminum, there is a layer of tin-lead alloy between the heat dissipation components, resulting in a much lower overall heat dissipation coefficient for copper car radiators.
Conclusion
Aluminium has the advantage of being lighter by 30% to 40%. This is a significant advantage over copper for a racer. When it comes to corrosion, neither has an advantage. A copper radiator core will turn green and deteriorate quickly if not protected, especially in a damp environment. As a result, copper radiators have always been painted, typically black. If aluminum is not protected from the elements, it will oxidize.
Which is superior, aluminum or copper? Each has distinct advantages over the other in various areas. Which to use in your specific case is determined by what is more important to you. Weight, appearance, uniqueness, and cost must all be considered before making a decision. Over the years, it has been discovered that a properly built high efficiency copper radiator will cool the same as a properly built aluminum radiator.
Last but not least, the sort of vehicle you drive—whether it's a heavy-duty truck or a personal car—determines the ideal radiator for you. A copper-brass radiator, for example, works well with an old car or a heavy-duty truck, whereas an aluminum radiator goes a long way for your personal car.
Once you start your engine, certain processes begin. The engine encounters friction which in turn creates heat. Over time a lot of heat will be generated. This is where the radiator plays its role. The primary purpose of the radiator is to prevent the overheating of the vehicle. Radiators is a heat exchanger that is part of the cooling system that dissipates heat by passing a coolant to the engine. Because of this important role, the radiators are essential for the normal functioning of the vehicle. So, the users have to make sure that the radiator is always in good working condition. If they find that the car’s engine is heating faster than expected, then the radiator has to be checked and replaced if necessary.
2
What Are The Different Types Of Radiators?In these types, a series of tubes are connected to the upper and lower tank through which the water passes. To improvise the heat transfer, fins are placed around them. As water passes through all the tubes in this type, a defect on even one tube will affect the entire cooling process.
Also referred to as a honeycomb radiator because of its appearance, this type of radiator allows the coolant to flow through the spaces between them. Air will pass through the tube and the coolant flows in the in-between spaces. The cellular core type has a great benefit over the tubular one because if the tubes are clogged it will only affect a small portion of the entire cooling surface.
In downflow radiators, the tanks are placed at the top and bottom of the core. These were usually found in older vehicles as they have a tall yet narrow width grille and radiator support. The advantage of the downflow radiator is its inlet and outlet placement. They can be placed at the center, left, right, or somewhere in between. But they have a limited cooling capacity.
In this type, the radiators are placed on the left and right sides of the core. You can usually find crossflow radiators in modern vehicles, as they are shorter and have wide grille openings. When it comes to performance, crossflow radiators are an excellent choice as they have several benefits over the other ones. Because of their large core, they remove more heat. The fluid passes slowly through the core and spends sufficient time in the air stream. Crossflow radiators are also available in double and triple pass designs. This enhances the ability of the radiator to cool by increasing the number of times the coolant passes through the core.
This type of radiator has an aluminum core with a plastic tank. This is the most common type and is found in modern vehicles. They are the least expensive and hence they are mass-produced by the auto manufacturers.
This type of radiator has a brass tank with a copper core. They were usually replaced by plastic and aluminum radiators as copper was quite expensive and when affected by corrosion, the repair costs were high. Though these radiators were bulky, with advancements over time, their weight was reduced to half. Though these radiators are reliable and function perfectly, their high cost and exposure to rust, led to their downfall.
To overcome the downfalls of the copper and brass radiators, auto manufacturers came up with plastic radiators. These radiators have an alloy core, yet they use a plastic tank to reduce weight. Though they weren’t as efficient as copper and brass, their reduced weight and low cost made them one of the common types of radiators used by auto manufacturers. But the issue with the plastic radiators was that fixing them was quite difficult as you have to replace the entire component in case of a defect. To overcome these issues, aluminum radiators came into existence.
One major issue with the plastic radiator was that the entire component had to be replaced if damaged. This needed to be avoided and that’s where the aluminum radiators came in as handy. Because of their high thermal conductivity, they can absorb heat faster. Their cooling efficiency and heat dispersion are much better compared to copper and brass and plastic. The main benefit of an aluminum radiator was that, if a certain part was damaged, you can replace them instead of the whole component but at a high cost. These radiators are the best suited for high-performance cars if you are looking for better performance.
The tanks located on either end of the radiator core, which is typically constructed of aluminum and conducts coolant through the cooling fins, are the key components that are made of plastic. According to Nationwide Plastics, the plastic used for the radiator tanks is glass-reinforced nylon. The high-softening-point nylon plastic helps the plastic radiator tank withstand the pressure and temperatures involved.